Home

Texas law dog bites another dog

While many states have a one-bite rule, which means that an owner cannot be held liable for a dog's attack unless the dog has a history of biting another person, Texas does not follow this law. Texas does not have a one-bite rule. Instead, there are two primary claims made against owners in dog bite cases There are a number of causes of action available to the victim of a dog attack in Texas. They include negligence, causing a dog bite by violating an animal control law, failing to stop a dog attack which is in progress, and keeping a dog that is known to be vicious Texas doesn't have a civil liability law specifically for dog bites, but that doesn't mean you won't be liable if your dog bites someone. The Texas Supreme Court articulated the law and standards that Texas follows for animal attacks in a case called Marshall v Under Texas Law, the damages you may recover for loss of a pet are limited to the reasonable cost of the pet unless the animal has some special characteristics that enable it to have a quantifiable value. Thus whether a dog attacks another dog or a dog is injured in a car accident, you are limited in what remedies you have

What is the current law in Texas in regard to dog bites

  1. al negligence, as defined by Section 6.03, Penal Code, fails to secure the dog and the dog makes an unprovoked attack on another person that occurs at a location other than the owner's real property or in or on the owner's motor vehicle or boat and that causes serious bodily injury, as defined by Section 1.07, Penal Code, or death to the other person; o
  2. The City of Carrollton, Texas, Animal Services Department asks that all residents report animal scratches and bites to local rabies control, as required by state law. A dog or other animal that bites or scratches a person, breaking the skin, must be quarantined at a state-approved facility for 10 days
  3. (a) When a dog, cat, or domestic ferret that has bitten a human has been identified, the custodian will place the animal (regardless of its vaccination status) in quarantine as defined in the Texas Health and Safety Code, §826.002, until the end of the 10-day observation period
  4. Dangerous dog laws: Check out your local state, municipal and neighborhood dog laws that ban or restrict the ownership of specific breeds of dog, or mixed breeds of dangerous dogs. When the dog who attacked your pet is a dangerous breed , the owner may be automatically negligent and liable for your losses
  5. Dog Owner/Custodian and the Texas Dangerous Dog Law Dog owner defined. HSC 822.041(5). Includes those with custody of a dog. Check local City ordinances and County orders for additional restrictions and requirements that may apply beyond State ·law. Authorized by Texas Health and Safety Code section 822.047. State law Does owner.
  6. d: If the attacking dog is already listed as a dangerous dog, the owner may be responsible for harboring an aggressive or violent animal and held liable for any damages or veterinary bills
Michigan Legal Blog | The Clark Law Office

Overview of Texas Dog Bite La

When a dog causes injury to another dog, the negligent dog owner has breached their duty of care. This means that they are liable for the dog's injuries and any other resulting damages. When it comes to a dog attacking another dog, damages include reimbursement for vet bills, dog medications, kennel fees while the dog is recovering, etc Texas state law specifically allows for any person witnessing an attack of one dog attacking another animal to kill the attacking dog. In these situations, the law states that the person who kills the dog is not liable for damages to the owner, keeper, or person in control of the dog

State of Texas laws regarding the regulation of dangerous dogs to prevent dog bites are found in Title 10 of the Texas Health and Safety Code. This law allows for the seizure of a dangerous dog that causes death or serious bodily injury Unlike most other states, Nevada does not have any set dog bite law statutes. However, the state operates closely with others that have strict liability rules for dog owners. No one-bite law exists - a dog owner can still be liable for damage caused by his or her pet, even if the dog has shown no previous signs of violent or aggressive.

Texas Dog Bite Laws - FindLa

All animal bites must be reported to Animal Protection. If medical attention has been received after a bite, download an Animal Bite Report and fax it to (512) 978-0617. Owners of dogs involved in bite cases must provide a current rabies vaccination certificate to Animal Protection If your dog has a history of biting people in the past, your pet is considered dangerous under the law. If your dog bites someone else on your property, you may be held strictly liable if you have not shown any warning sign or indication that there is a dangerous dog on your property. Repeat offenders are labelled as violators of the one bite. Dog owners are responsible for their pets' actions, including when one dog bites another dog. Even without an explicit statute addressing dogs biting other dogs, owners must pay damages, including vet bills, when their dog bites another dog. California law classifies pets as property

The Texas Health and Safety Code says, A dog or a coyote that is attacking, is about to attack, or has recently attacked livestock, domestic animals, or fowls, may be killed by any person witnessing the attack, or the attacked animal's owner, or a person acting on behalf of the owner, if the owner or person has knowledge of the attack. Texas follows the common law principle that a victim of a dog bite may recover compensation from the owner or keeper of a dog if: (1) the dog previously bit a person or showed aggression towards a person; and (2) the owner or keeper of the dog was aware of the dog's conduct prior to biting the victim What is the Law in Texas Regarding Dog Bites? Texas requires dog owners to use reasonable care to prevent the animal from causing injuries. Basically, if the owner's negligence led to the dog attack, or if a dangerous dog attacks someone; the owner can be sued and possibly sent to jail

Below are the relevant parts of the Houston Code of Ordinances that contain the various leash laws and dangerous dog laws which may apply when a City of Houston dog bite occurs. The city of Houston has a fairly comprehensive set of regulations that are very similar to Texas Health and Safety Code Section, 822 Search Texas Statutes. (a) A person commits an offense if the person is the owner of a dog and the person: (1) with criminal negligence, as defined by Section 6.03, Penal Code , fails to secure the dog and the dog makes an unprovoked attack on another person that occurs at a location other than the owner's real property or in or on the owner's. Below you will find a list of dog bite laws in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, including state statutes, whether a state holds owners strictly liable for dog bite injuries, and any additional provisions. Remember, state dog bite laws are a combination of local and state laws and are subject to change

Dangerous and Aggressive Dogs. It is now a criminal offense to allow an unsecured dog to make an unprovoked bite causing bodily injury to a person, domestic animal, or livestock. Sec. 822.041. of the State Code defines a dangerous dog as a dog that Under current law, even a provoked dog kept on a leash can be euthanized if its attack results in severe bodily injury, which the statute defines as severe bite wounds or severe ripping.

In Texas, in order to recover damages for a dog bite (even one that leads to death), the injured person must show that the dog's owner (you) knew the dog had bitten someone before or had acted aggressively in the past Dog bites can lead to serious injuries, and in some cases, emotional trauma. But determining who's at fault for the dog bite - the victim or the dog owner - depends on whether or not the victim provoked the dog. By law, provocation is any action from a person that elicits a radical change in the dog's behavior The dog may become fearful of other dogs and the owner may become tense every time another dog approaches. Check if your home owner's insurance covers any bites caused by your dog to third parties. If it's not covered, it comes out of your pocket, because refusing to pay the vet bill may cause the owner to seek legal action in a small.

Overview of Dog Bites. Dogs have shared their lives with humans for more than 12,000 years and that coexistence has contributed substantially to humans' quality of life. In the United States, there are more than 53 million dogs sharing the human-canine bond, more dogs per capita than in any other country in the world But it looks to me like the law goes kind of gray when the dog is attacking you or another human being. That gets into the dangerous dog area of the law, and in that matter the law gets picky.

Dallas Animal Services will investigate the incident. A person may request an affidavit to initiate a dangerous dog investigation. See affidavit forms above or you can also call 214-670-8313 to have an affidavit mailed or faxed to you. More information on dog bites can be found here With nearly 90 million pet dogs in the U.S. and about 4.5 million dog bites every year, it's no surprise that lawsuits over the resulting injuries are also common. Depending on the circumstances and where the injury happened, the victim may file a civil suit based on the dog owner's negligence or on a strict liability dog-bite law that makes the owner liable regardless of the animal's. Overview of Texas Dog Bite Law. 9 hours ago Dogbitelaw.com Related Item . There are a number of causes of action available to the victim of a dog attack in Texas. They include negligence, causing a dog bite by violating an animal control law, failing to stop a dog attack which is in progress, and keeping a dog that is known to be vicious.One Bite Rule. . Texas adheres to the so-called one bite animal bites, ensuring proper management of biting animals, and enforcing state and local rabies laws. What happens to the animal that bites a person? Dogs, Cats, and Ferrets (Domestic): Regardless of vaccination status, the dog, cat, or ferret must be quarantined or euthanized (humanely killed). If euthanized, do not damage the brain, as it.

What Recourse Do I Have If A Dog Attacks Another Dog?

What Recourse Do I Have If A Dog Attacks Another Dog

Texas laws regarding animal attacks, including dog bite cases, fall into the categories of 1) Negligent handling of animals, 2) Strict liability - prior attacks by an animal with a prior history of being dangerous or vicious, 3) Negligence per se - violation of an ordinance or law San Antonio's dangerous and aggressive dog laws are taken directly from State law (Health and Safety Code § 822.0421). Their mission is to prevent future dog bites or attacks from happening by requiring safeguards that protect people from a specific dog who has been involved in a documented, unprovoked incident The Act includes incidents on private property. Since 1991 it has been illegal for dogs to be 'out of control in a public place'. In 2014 the law was amended to include incidents on private property - so inside your home and others' homes, including front and back gardens. Your dog is considered dangerously out of control if it: Injures someone In other words, Texas dogs gets one free bite before its owner is liable for damages. Texas' lack of dog bite statute is at odds with the majority of states because the one bite rule shields a dog owner from liability each time one of his dogs bites a person for the first time unless it can be proved that the owner knew that the dog had the.

Wrongful Death Attorney Houston - Accidental Death Lawyer CA

For example, a dangerous dog could be defined as a specific breed, a dog that has bit a person in the past and/or a dog that has bit another domesticated animal in the past. The association should also require an owner of a dangerous dog or breed to have homeowner's insurance that covers liability for a dog attack, so there is a source of. The common law rule for dog bites was that a dog owner could only be liable for a bite if the owner knew or should have known of the dogs dangerous or vicious propensities. It was under common law that the one bite rule emerged, the general rule that an owner cannot be liable for a dog's first bite, under the theory that until a dog actually. Texas & Federal Laws. Chapter 821 of the Texas Health and Safety Code. This chapter, Treatment of Animals, discusses the treatment of animals that are impounded or seized, outlining the process when local officials seize an animal due to cruel treatment. This section also describes acceptable euthanasia methods and unlawful restraint of dogs

In most cases, the dog's owner will have coverage under his or her homeowners insurance policy for valid dog bite injury claims. What Are The Dog Owner Liability Laws In Texas? Any person who owns a dog - regardless of vicious or dangerous propensity - should carry personal liability coverage of at least $300,000 that covers potential dog. Updated: 9:29 PM CDT May 20, 2021. FRISCO, Texas — Frisco Animal Services is currently investigating after a dog owned by Dallas Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott reportedly bit two people. The dog owner is, of course, the person with primary legal liability, if any (different states apply different standards regarding when a dog owner is legally liable for a bite), but that dog owner may not have the funds to cover the alleged damages or may have fled the scene The law also helps protect other animals in case something goes wrong like if a dog bites another dog. Markmann says in that situation, the animals are treated as property and the police or animal.

How To Handle a PI Claim - Aulsbrook Law Firm, PLLC

Dog owners can be held liable for dog bite injuries if they knew the dog was likely to cause that type of injury. In other words, victims must prove the owners knew their dogs posed a danger. The name of these types of laws comes from the idea that if the dog has bitten or attacked someone before and the owner was aware of the problem, they. Overview of Dog Bite Strict Liability Laws. Go directly to Table of Dog Bite Strict Liability Laws.Approximately 36 states and D.C. have strict liability for dog bites. Although there are exceptions, liability is typically assigned regardless of the dog's former showing of vicious tendencies or the owner's prior knowledge of the dog's viciousness Unless you work with dogs or cats, you have been bitten by a dog or cat, or your dog or cat has bitten or scratched someone, you might not know that the Texas Rabies Control Act of 1981 requires. Map of Dog Bite Laws - Presented by the Animal Legal and Historical Center, this interactive map provides links to state laws regarding dog bite liability. If you have more questions about animal attacks and dog bites, or need legal assistance with a claim, consider meeting with a personal injury lawyer in your neighborhood While humans rarely provoke dogs, other dogs do much more often. Usually, this is what brings out the worst in a good pet- another aggressive dog. Regardless of which dog moved first, a dogfight.

El Paso Dog/Animal Attack Attorney. El Paso dog bite lawyers at Ruhmann Law Firm represent individuals who have suffered injury from dog bites and other animal attacks in West Texas, Arizona or Southern New Mexico. If you have been bitten, don't assume that the bite is not serious enough to recover money damages Animal Protection handles dangerous and vicious dogs in Travis County. Call 9-1-1 if a dog seems dangerous and is threatening. If you suspect a dog is dangerous or if a dog kills or severely injures a pet or person, you can seek a vicious or dangerous dog designation. You must submit a signed bite affidavit to Animal Protection Female dogs can be aggressive during stages of their reproductive cycles. Leash your dog (as required by law) to prevent him/her from approaching other dogs and people. Some people are afraid of dogs. Other dogs may not be as well trained as yours. Some dogs bite when they feel afraid, so socialize your dog While most of the time an owner must have prior knowledge of the dog's tendency to bite, some states have enacted laws that make an owner liable for any bite regardless of the owner's knowledge (called, strict liability laws). I n most dog bite cases, the issue of an owner's knowledge is central. But, even in states with strict liability. I am Georgetown dog bite lawyer . At The Law Office of Carl Knickerbocker, P.C., I represent injured people and their families in Texas personal injury claims stemming from dog attacks. I can advise and represent you if your case involves: Puncture wounds to the skin; Lacerations on the face or bod

If Your Dog Bites. If you find that your dog has bitten another dog, check and secure your dog then seek out the bitten dog's owner. The owners can then exchange information and establish guidelines for contact (e.g. I will take my dog to the veterinarian tomorrow morning and call you with the results) Yes, dog bite insurance is a regular part of your homeowners coverage. This is part of your liability coverage, which protects you from lawsuits and covers damages for household mishaps. It may also be covered under a section of your policy called medical payments, although this part of your policy has a low maximum — usually around $5K A person may innocently and unintentionally provoke a dog. If, for example, you accidentally step on a dog's tail, that's provocation. 27 Or if a toddler tries to hug a strange dog, and the dog turns and bites the child, the dog's owner will probably not be liable for the injury, regardless of the dog's prior behavior. 28 Unlike many other states, Nevada does not have a statewide dog bite statute.However, under state law, an owner whose dog bites another person faces civil liability for a lawsuit when the animal has shown a previous history of aggression of which the owner should have been aware.. More specifically, an owner is held liable in a dog bite case when

1 Answer | Asked in Animal / Dog Law for Texas on Jan 2, 2021. Q: My neighbor lets her dog roam free on our block, the dog is in heat and attracting other dogs to the block. I can't walk my dogs freely without fear of being attacked by the pack of dogs her dog has attracted According to the Center for Disease Control (CDC), there are around 4.5 million dog bite accidents each year. Around 800,000 need medical care due to those bites. There are around 330 million Americans each year. Thus, one out of every 73 people suffers a dog bite. Texas takes the lead in fatal dog bites. Read More: Dog Bite Statistic

Dog Bite Attorney Austin | Animal Attack Injuries LawyersNYC Scaffolding Collapse Reminds Us of the Need forHow Do Texas Reckless Driving Laws Stack Up | Reckless

An experienced dog bite lawyer will know the laws in your area. When you are injured by a dog bite, it's important to speak to a lawyer. Many times, if the injury happened during a dog fight, the insurance company for the other dog owner may try to blame you and your dog for prolonging the fight The dog bite law applies to any damages caused when a dog attacks or injures another person. This includes both dog bite injuries and injuries caused by other dog-related behaviors. For instance, if a dog causes injuries by jumping on a person and knocking her down, that person could seek damages under Minnesota's dog bite law Top San Antonio Animal & Dog Bites Lawyers - Texas (11 results with ads) If you or a loved one has suffered an animal bite injury, including dog bites and injuries caused by other domesticated animals, an animal bite lawyer can help. You may be entitled to recover from an animal owner, business, or facility, regardless of whether the owner.

HEALTH AND SAFETY CODE CHAPTER 822

A dog bite is a bite upon a person or other animal by a dog; especially from a rabid dog. More than one successive bite is often called a dog attack, although dog attacks can include knock-downs and scratches.Though many dog bites do not result in injury, they can result in infection, disfigurement, temporary or permanent disability, or death.Another type of dog bite is the soft bite. Animal control might rule in the dog's favor if they find underlying reasons for a dog bite. An example of this is if your dog was bred for fighting or faced other forms of animal abuse. They might discover an abused dog injured its abusive owner If you or a loved one has suffered an animal bite injury, including dog bites and injuries caused by other domesticated animals, an animal bite lawyer can help. You may be entitled to recover from an animal owner, business, or facility, regardless of whether the owner (or animal keeper) did anything to protect you from being attacked

Texas Cities Towns Animal Ordinances - Texas Dog Bite La

A cat owner may be liable for its injuries that it has inflicted. Some settings that previous courts have considered include: Store owners who knew that their cat was prone to being aggressive has a duty to keep a safe business environment. The owner knew of the cat's violent behavior and let the cat roam free without constraint, resulting in. The owner of each domestic dog or cat shall have the animal vaccinated against rabies by four months of age as required in Chapter 169 of the Texas Administrative Code Rule 169.29. The animal must receive a booster within the twelve-month interval following initial vaccination Texas has put the law in place to address these issues and concerns. Texas Laws Regarding The Restraint of Dogs. According to Texas laws, you cannot simply just chain your dog to something and let that solve the issue. Sec. 821.077 sets out to address owners who attempt to restrain their dog by chain or rope: Unlawful Restraint of Dog Every state has different laws regarding a dog owner's liability for dog bites. Some states follow their common law. Other states have enacted statutory law in the form of Dog Bite Statutes. Most often, a Dog Bite Statute abolishes the common law, because, unlike the common law, these statutes don't require a dog bite victim to prove that a dog. If you suspect a dog is dangerous and it has met the guidelines required by Texas law, an investigation may be conducted to determine if the dog is a Dangerous Dog or a Aggressive Dog. _____ DANGEROUS DOG. Texas Health and Safety Code Sec. 822.041 Dangerous dog means a dog that: (A) makes an unprovoked attack on a person that causes bodily.

Texas Administrative Code - Secretary of State of Texa

SECTION 47-3-110. Liability for attacks by dogs, provoked attacks, trained law enforcement dogs. (A) If a person is bitten or otherwise attacked by a dog while the person is in a public place or is lawfully in a private place, including the property of the dog owner or person having the dog in the person's care or keeping, the dog owner or person having the dog in the person's care or keeping. Dog Bite Law: The most trusted dog bite law website on the Internet is DogBiteLaw.com by attorney Kenneth Phillips. His website provides a wealth of information for dog bite victims, attorneys, dog owners, landlords and parents. The website also provides detailed information on state dog bite laws for all 50 states. For Dog Bite Victims: This. leashed big dog bites unleashed little dog, Dogs, 21 replies Unleashed dog bites another unleashed dog., Dogs, 54 replies My Leashed dog bit another leashed dog, Dogs, 21 replies My Leashed Dog Was Attacked By Unleashed Dog, Dogs, 12 replies unleashed dog bites leashed dog and unleashed dog owner gets bitten, Dogs, 27 replie Another thing to note is that if you live in an area with dangerous dog laws, your dog will most likely be put to sleep whether the other owner seeks that action or not. What to do After Your Dog Kills Another Dog. If your dog kills another dog, and you were not at fault, there's probably nothing for you to do

Flat Road Driving Dangers In West Texas | Liggett Law Group

Who Pays When a Dog Bites Another Dog

The owner is trying to protect their dog from something on the other side of their fence (kids, another dog, etc.) by keeping the dog in one area in the yard. The owner's fence is damaged or the owner doesn't have a fenced yard. The dog's behavior makes keeping them indoors challenging and the owner doesn't know how to correct the behavior Dog bites can cause significant injury to the skin and soft tissues. The dog's teeth and jaws are very powerful and the wounds they inflict can crush or tear muscles and skin, penetrate through the chest wall causing lung collapse, or cause serious or fatal damage to intestinal organs. Even a bite that does not break the skin can cause crushing. Dogs, Cats, and Ferrets. Dogs, cats, and ferrets that are currently vaccinated with a USDA-licensed rabies vaccine should be revaccinated immediately, kept under the owner's control, and observed for 45 days. If the animal under observation develops any signs of illness, it should be evaluated by a veterinarian tel: (919) 918-0348. Private message. Call. Message. Profile. Posted on Dec 13, 2009. Yes. Look at California Code section 3342 which states that, The owner of any dog is liable for the damages suffered by any person who is bitten by the dog while in a public place or lawfully in a private place, including the property of the owner of the.

The dogs were secured, and one of them, a Rottweiler, the dog that bit the two people, was placed in a 10-day quarantine per Texas law. Elliott received three citations, one for each dog, for Dog at Large. The injured were taken to hospitals. It's not believed their injuries are life-threatening. No other charges have been filed Level 2: The dog actually bites the victim and achieves tooth on skin contact, but causes no puncture wound. Level 3: The dog's bite penetrates the victim's skin, but the wound is shallower than the length of a canine tooth. Level 4: The dog not only bites, but he clamps down and/or shakes his head too. Because of the clamping and pressure. Scott Sheaffer is a certified dog behavior consultant located in Dallas, Texas. Scott Sheaffer, CBCC-KA, CDBC, CPDT-KA, specializes in the assessment and treatment of fear, anxiety, aggression and phobias in dogs six months and older. Aggression (7 types) Separation Anxiety. Resource Guarding of Food, Toys, Bed. Fear. Inappropriate Urination

Legal Rights When Another Dog Attacks Your Do

DOG BITE LAWS IN ALL 50 STATES (00212539) Just Now Mwl-law.com Related Item . Other states base liability on statutes which create liability in the absence of scienter, negligence or intentional behavior. These are referred to as statutory strict liability states and vary from state to state. They sometimes hold the owner liable automatically if their dog bites somebody States will have their own dangerous dog law. Some counties and cities also have dangerous dog laws. These laws will vary as to what behavior is deemed dangerous. In some, one bite can lead to a dangerous dog determination; in others, the dog must have bitten more than once. Similarly, some jurisdictions may consider a dog dangerous if that dog. Austin, TX - Lillian's Law ( HB 1355) is the new Texas State dangerous dog law. Under the law, the owner of a loose dog that causes injury or death can be prosecuted if the owner is found to be criminally negligent in failing to prevent the dog from escaping. The third-degree felony charge can bring a sentence of 2 to 10 years in prison and a.

Beware of Dog Bite Laws in Texas: Criminal Penalties for

The dog bit someone. This would be considered vicious behavior. According to the pet agreement, the dog and/or tenant should no longer live in the property. If the landlord did not follow through on this contract, and the dog bites another person, the landlord could be liable Bites of squirrels, hamsters, guinea pigs, gerbils, chipmunks, rats, mice, other small rodents, rabbits, and hares almost never require rabies postexposure prophylaxis. The quarantine period is a precaution against the remote possibility that an animal may appear healthy, but actually be sick with rabies. The likelihood of rabies in a domestic. Dog owner who is a tenant not homeowner, allows dog to roam common areas, while not on leash held by capable person. Common areas owned by the HOA. CC&R say that HOA has duty to keep common areas safe. Is there liability only for an actual dog bite or also for injuries caused to person trying to get away from the aggressive dog in the common area Dogs may bite in defense of themselves, their territory, or a member of their pack. Mother dogs will fiercely protect their puppies as well. Startling a dog, such as waking one up or a child suddenly approaching from behind, can provoke a dog bite. Hurting a dog even if by accident like pushing on sore hips in an older dog can provoke a bite as.

Fatal car accident on North 610 Loop at Ella Boulevard

It does not matter if the dog was present to provide emotional comfort to its owner — if it bites another person, the owner is liable. This is particularly true when the owner knows that his or her dog has not been specially trained to tolerate being in a store or restaurant, or if the pet has a history of being aggressive See chart on state's vicious animals law. Lack of a specific dog bite strict liability statute does not mean that liability may not attach under other theories of liability, such as negligence, nuisance, or willful misconduct of various kinds. Click here. Arizona. Ariz. Rev. Stats. Secs. 11-1025 through 102 All states have liability laws. Not all have dog-specific laws. What this means is that in some states, the laws as they relate to dog bites don't have much to do with the other liability laws. You could go to court under a dog bite statute, or under another liability statute If a dog has bitten you or another person, and it has since retreated, if it is still on the loose and still a danger to others, you may be able to pursue the dog. Once the dog is back in the custody of its owner, and the situation has been controlled, do not show up at your neighbor's door brandishing a weapon B. Dangerous Dog Statute/3 P.S. Section 459-501-A through Section 459-507-A Originally, the statute departed very little from the common law on civil liability. The statute, originally, stated that in order to hold an owner criminally liable for a dog bite there had to be evidence of a dog's history or propensity to attack without.